Two identical finite bodies of constant heat capacity at temperatures T1 and T2 are available to do work in a heat engine. The final temperature Tf reached by the bodies on delivery of maximum work is

This question was previously asked in
ESE Mechanical 2014 Official Paper - 1
View all UPSC IES Papers >
  1. \({T_F} = \frac{{{T_1} + {T_2}}}{2}\)
  2. \({T_f} = \sqrt {{T_1}{T_2}} \)
  3. Tf = T1­ = T2
  4. \({T_f} = \sqrt {T_1^2 + T_2^2} \)

Answer (Detailed Solution Below)

Option 2 : \({T_f} = \sqrt {{T_1}{T_2}} \)
Free
ST 1: UPSC ESE (IES) Civil - Building Materials
6.2 K Users
20 Questions 40 Marks 24 Mins

Detailed Solution

Download Solution PDF

Explanation:

F2 Sumit Madhu 10.08.20 D 3

Assume T1 > T2

Q1 = cp (T1 - TF)

Q2 = cp (TF – T2)

∴ W = Q1 – Q2 = cp (T1 + T2 – 2TF)

For ‘w’ to be max, TF to be minimum

\({\rm{\Delta }}{S_1} = \mathop \smallint \limits_{{T_1}}^{{T_F}} {C_p}\frac{{dT}}{T} = {C_p}\;ln\frac{{{T_F}}}{{{T_1}}}\)

\({\rm{\Delta }}{S_2} = \mathop \smallint \limits_{{T_2}}^{{T_F}} {C_p}\frac{{dT}}{T} = {C_p}\;ln\frac{{{T_F}}}{{{T_2}}}\)

As,

\({\left( {{\rm{\Delta }}S} \right)_{univ}} \ge 0\;\;\;\therefore {C_p}\;ln\frac{{{T_F}}}{{{T_1}}} + {C_p}\;ln\frac{{{T_F}}}{{{T_2}}} \ge 0\)

\(\therefore {C_p}\;ln\left[ {\frac{{T_F^2}}{{{T_1}{T_2}}}} \right] \ge 0\)

Now,

For TF to be minimum

\(ln\frac{{T_F^2}}{{{T_1}{T_2}}} = 0\;\;\;\therefore ln\frac{{T_F^2}}{{{T_1}{T_2}}} = ln\;1\)

\(\therefore {T_F} = \sqrt {{T_1}{T_2}} \)

Latest UPSC IES Updates

Last updated on May 28, 2025

->  UPSC ESE admit card 2025 for the prelims exam has been released. 

-> The UPSC IES Prelims 2025 will be held on 8th June 2025.

-> The selection process includes a Prelims and a Mains Examination, followed by a Personality Test/Interview.

-> Candidates should attempt the UPSC IES mock tests to increase their efficiency. The UPSC IES previous year papers can be downloaded here.

More Second Law of Thermodynamics and Entropy Questions

Get Free Access Now
Hot Links: teen patti master apk best all teen patti teen patti all